The journey from there to here
Published on January 17, 2006 By Gideon MacLeish In Current Events

NOTE: This article was inspired in large part by a fellow JoeUser's attempt to get U2 tickets. Because the opinion expressed in this article was WHOLLY inappropriate to that thread, it wasn't posted there. But I did feel an acknowledgement was in order.

In a recent discussion about obtaining U2 tickets, I could not help but think about the band, who is inextricably linked to efforts to eradicate world poverty through the highly prominent efforts of its front man, Bono. While I disagree with Bono's methods (yes, I have an alternative solution and have mentioned it many times), I highly respect the fact that he brought the issue to the table. That started me thinking: how much consideration do I put into a group or person's political point of view before attending their concerts or otherwise patronizing the fruits of their labor? The answer, I found, surprisingly, was: not much.

Two of my favorite actors are Susan Sarandon and Tim Robbins. We really couldn't be much further apart politically. But the fact is, if they are in a movie (chick flicks nothwithstanding for Sarandon, although I'm a fair bit more flexible with a movie with her in it than most others), I will usually put it high on my "to see" list because they pick their projects well, and usually choose compelling roles that leave you appreciating the time you spent. And, although I am not a huge fan of one of his "signature" hits (Lynyrd Skynyrd already expressed my POV on this, no need to rehash it now), I would go to a Neil Young concert any time you asked. Bob Dylan? Pete Seeger? Just put the tickets in my hand, and show me the way.

One of the best concerts I ever attended was at the WOMAD (world of music, art and cance) theatre outside Chicago, and featured Midnight Oil, among others. Midnight Oil's politics could not be described as anything short of far left, but man, did they put on a show. Even though I must point out I WAS "far left" at the time, I would not hesitate to go back, given the opportunity.

In short, when I go to see a movie, it's about the show. When I go to the concert, it's about the music. The bands, actors, and other entertainers, in my opinion, are free to express any point of view they choose (David Bowie's fascination with fascism comes to mind), as long as they put on a good show while I'm sitting out front.


Comments
on Jan 17, 2006
David Bowie likes Facism?  I never knew.  But like you, I watch for the same reasons.
on Jan 17, 2006
The first time I realized that it was the music (or movies) they make, not the person making it was Elton John. He was probably my first "favorite" artist. When he "came out" it really rocked the pop world... but not my love for his music (especially the early years).

I too like Susan Serandon's films (although, she'll always be "Janet" to me). The Dixie Chicks... I'd be one of them in the crowd with a "Bush/Cheney" T-shirt... but I'd love to see them in concert. Neil Young has always been a favorite too (but not in politics).

The ONLY celeb I can think of whose politics has made "it" so vile to me that I could never bring myself to see anything "it" has done is hanoijane. I even remember liking a few of its movies before I learned of "its" crimes against humanity. Now, I'd rather drink vomit than throw any support "its" way.
on Jan 17, 2006
Midnight Oil's politics could not be described as anything short of far left, but man, did they put on a show.

I love their music, they have great harmonies and excellent musicianship. Especially "Blue Sky Mining" and "The Dead Heart".

And I love their political message. They are my definitive political band, more so than U2. But maybe I don't find their music politically offensive because I am so distanced from Aboriginal property rights...
on Jan 18, 2006
Good post, Gid. I can think of several personal examples where I love the art, but try to overlook the politics - Frank Sinatra to name but the most obvious.

That said, I agree with ParaTed2k, that sometimes the politics is just too much to overlook. In my case, that applies to the likes of Eric Clapton (oh he has mellowed, but I cannot forgive him for his vile racism during the 1970s), Charlton Heston, Bruce Willis (who had the gall to complain about his tax bill in an interview in 'The Big Issue'!), Sting (nominally 'liberal' I suppose, but such a hypocrite) ...

'David Bowie likes Facism? I never knew.'
Not any more, I think it's fair to say. He flirted with the imagery and some of the ideological trappings towards the end of the 1970s (circa 'Station to Station'), when he was pretty lost in a haze of cocaine, mysticism and paranoia.
on Jan 18, 2006

Eric Clapton (oh he has mellowed, but I cannot forgive him for his vile racism during the 1970s),

You see that shows how much I pay attention to the artists statements.  I had no idea about Bowie, or Clapton, yet both are 2 of my favorites. I dont think their views bled over into their music, and that is probably why I never had a clue on their 'checkered' beliefs.