The journey from there to here
Published on December 21, 2005 By Gideon MacLeish In Current Events

Well, today we took the children to speak with the CPS investigator. We brought along our faithful tape recorder, and the children played together in a room while the investigator interviewed them.

One point I would like to make (briefly) that came up from a question in the course of interview (which our five year old handled FAMOUSLY...more on that later), is that I am fat and my wife and children are slender. My wife has always been slender, and we've educated our children on good eating habits so that hopefully they overcome any genetic predisposition towards obesity. This leads certain less-than-kind individuals to assume that I'm eating all the food while the wife and kids starve (ignoring the fact that I have LOST over 100 pounds and kept it off for about two years). This is a form of legal discrimination, and frankly, it is INCREDIBLY hurtful.

The reason this point is relevant is that the investigator asked all the children whether they had enough to eat (fair enough). With my five year old, who was the most chatty, she followed up with "who eats the MOST?" (a loaded question with a pretty obvious answer, if the absolute truth were told). My five year old smiles and answered "I do". Score one for the good guys!

But what made me REALLY proud of her was when the investigator answered whether she was afraid of anyone, child or adult. When she said "yes", I held my breath. When the investigator asked WHO she was afraid of, she answered "the person who called CPS on us. We didn't do anything wrong".

Because this answer didn't come out of the oldest two, it was obviously NOT a coached answer. Now, while it COULD come back to haunt us, I doubt it. She didnt say she was afraid of CPS, but of "the person who CALLED CPS on us". I'd say that's as good a grounds as any to pursue a false allegation charge against our accusers, personally.

We don't know what will come of the interview, but we cannot be accused of noncompliance. We are gaining ground slowly but surely in our fight against the unconstitutional acts often employed by CPS. The best proof of that is the fact that once again, a home visit was NOT requested (although many parents are instructed that it is "mandatory")


Comments
on Dec 21, 2005
Sounds like it went well!  I hope they drop the whole thing now.
on Dec 21, 2005
I do, too...but I'm proud that I've raised children who are as much of a firebrand as their dad!
on Dec 21, 2005
Actually, rather than dropping the whole thing, I would hope the turn the false charges back on the idiot that filed the complaint to begin with. Have CPS or other social services start poking through all of that individual(s) business and see how they like having everything they do scrutinized. I'd hazzard a pretty safe guess/bet that they wouldn't like it one bit.

As I've said before, I pretty much despise busy-bodies. I do worry about other's childrens, don't want to see abusive situations continue, but it's damned hard to draw conclusions from just a few minutes of interaction, or even a few hours that someone might see over the course of a few days or more of being a neighbor.

Unless you've walked more than a mile in another's shoes, you have no way of knowing the real situation. If there's no bruises, and no obvious physical abuse then things should proceed very slowly and cautiously, and if after a preliminary investigation it can be shown that charges are baseless, they need to be dropped completely and a notation should be made to start ignoring the baseless claims that the busy-body files.

It is very sad that those that cry wolf will wind up costing everyone all of these problems, and worse yet that others that might really need help may not get it because of time wasted looking into non-starters.
on Dec 21, 2005
Good Gid. I am so glad it went well. And it does sound like it went well.

I think they will send you a letter saying they have to keep the case open for 90 days or whatever is Tex law, then they'll close it if not further complaints are launched.

But as terp referenced. I'd make SURE to go on record, their file records, saying you are being (or were being) harassed by the individual you think called CPS. In future, with that in the file, they will ask her way harder questions and be much less accommodating. Or at the very least that is how its supposed to work....I dunno how it will go where you are.....things are weird there.

Again, glad it went well!

T