The journey from there to here

I weep for the state of public education today.

If the teachers who blog regularly on this site are any education, FAR too many of our teachers are graduating with the notion that they are ALWAYS right and that there is no room for debating their position (inbloom, alisonwatkins, and select others, this does NOT apply to you). Worse yet, they apparently lack the skills to read in context.

The whole topic was keyed off when an educator discussed a situation they had  handled. I felt it could have been handled differently, in a way that was more respective of the rights of all concerned, but rather than post a nasty diatribe, I posted constructive criticism. In the second paragraph of my column, I even explained that I understood the person was well meaning but those were some helpful suggestions for the NEXT time.

I was flamed for it. The very person who had asked for advice apparently only wanted "advice" that praised them as a hero, as the brave soldier who protected their children from big, bad, evil mommy. The fact is, I didn't see it that way, and I wasn't going to PRETEND to see it that way.

We should all be VERY concerned when our educators have such poor social skills that they can't handle the slightest criticism without flying off the handle. When they are expected to teach our children how to arbitrate disputes and cannot themselves interact diplomatically with others to arbitrate their OWN disputes. And, even worse, when they are PAID with state dollars, to EDUCATE their children, yet spend an inordinate amount of time on the computer blogging during time they are PAID to be teaching, grading, or preparing lesson plans.


Comments
on Dec 08, 2005
I came, I saw, I wrote...and I deleted.

I was trying to play Peacekeeper. It's not going to work
on Dec 08, 2005

I wanted to play peacekeeper as well, frankly. I thought my response was VERY diplomatic.

Some people, however, thrive on chaos. I think that's at the core of it.

on Dec 08, 2005
Sorry Gideon, I missed that thread.  But as to your point, I think the higher up the education chain you go (not from BS to MS to ED, but Elementary, Secondary, Collegiate), the more arrogant and omniscience they become.  Having worked in education, I usually find the lower grade teachers to be very good and willing to learn, while the upper grades one (and yes, then College) have a god complex that just will not quit.
on Dec 08, 2005

Sadly, Dr. Guy, the God complex seems to be trickling down to elementary educators, even those who are unable to obtain gainful employment in that field despite an alleged shortage.

Go figure.

on Dec 09, 2005
For what it is worth, I am an educator, and the Internet server at my school will not allow any blog sites to penetrate the firewall. Therefore, I must use of my own time to keep up with blogs like the one above.

Just out of curiosity. Does your disdain for teachers have anything to do with your choice to homeschool?
on Dec 09, 2005

Just out of curiosity. Does your disdain for teachers have anything to do with your choice to homeschool?

My disdain for teachers? Did I not SPECIFICALLY mention two teachers to whom this standard does not apply? And did I not make it PATENTLY clear there were others I hadn't mentioned? Thank you for reinforcing my point about reading in context!

I do not have a disdain for teachers by any stretch of the imagination. I DO have a disdain for ANYONE in ANY profession who attempts to convert others to their way of thinking by force and personal attacks. If that is what teachers are being taught to do now, then it would be fair to say I have a disdain for teachers. But I believe it to be the individual's OWN agenda, and not that of their profession, that drives this way of thinking

(in other words, don't put words in my mouth).

I DO have a disdain for the public education system as it all too often exists in our society, yes. And you CAN quote me on that (as long as you don't shorten it with ellipses).