The journey from there to here
Published on June 27, 2005 By Gideon MacLeish In Politics

To steal and twist a metaphor from one of my favorite alternative medicine practitioners of all time, Capitalism is the greatest thing in the world, except for a nice MLT (mutton, lettuce and tomato...where the mutton is nice and lean and the tomatoes are just ripe!). I love capitalism. There is almost unlimited potential for human achievement within the infrastructure of a capitalist society.

But I detest consumerism. We are not just a material culture, we are a culture obsessed with disposable objects. I can't stand getting a drink from a fast food restaurant in a paper or styrofoam cup that I can't reuse as a TV drink cup or even as a sandbox scoop for the children. I never saw the purpose in having a drawer full of knives or more than two full sets of dishes...one regular, one formal. As for pots and pans, you don't need more of any one type than you have burners, and, let's face it, folks...there's only so many ways to blend/slice/grate something.

But the area where consumerism is starting to truly frighten me is in medications. We believe that we need a medication for every little symptom that starts up, when the truth is that all too often the best prescription is a little sleep and a lot of fluids. We don't believe that we should have to be subject to emotional highs and lows, but should tranquilize ourselves into a numbed, stoic state. It is, we believe in our best interest.

I fear a nation where one is so doped up on the tranquilizer of the week that they are no longer mesmerized by the awesome beauty of the Chicago skyline as they approach over Lake Michigan. Where the Grand Canyon is just a big ditch because the magic of the "house of stone and light" was lost somewhere back over Hoover Dam with the last dose of Paxil washed down with a Dr. Pepper. Where the magic of the playground is forever forgotten as our stepfordesque progeny await their turns at the slide devoid of any ability to conjure up the magic world of imagination that produces a dragon at its base that will devour you if you don't disembark at the precise second.

Sure, there will be fewer broken legs, fewer homicides, fewer suicides. Sure we will be a more orderly society. But where will be the daVincis when all who possess that potential are locked away in a telemarketer's office forever because a high school guidance counselor and a psychiatrist convinced them of the futility of their daydreams? The same madnesses that brought us the Dahmers and Geins of the world also brought us the Poes and the Van Goghs and their unmistakable contributions to the world we know and (those of us not yet on a prescription of choice) have come to love.

So let's say no to the mindset that demands we dope ourselves up beyond the ability to feel, to love, and yes, even to hate and fear. Let's say "yes" to the wondrous magic that is brought about by a world in which emotion is so important.


Comments
on Jun 27, 2005
The same madnesses that brought us the Dahmers and Geins of the world also brought us the Poes and the Van Goghs


Equating the first set with the second set is not something I would do. I see your point, but fans of Van Gogh and Poe are not going to be too appreciative.
on Jun 27, 2005
lol...I understand, dr. guy, but that's the point I am trying to make. While much bad has come about because of peoples' screwed up heads, much good has come about as well.
on Jun 27, 2005
While much bad has come about because of peoples' screwed up heads, much good has come about as well.


Quite true. The line between madness and genius is a thin one indeed.

Excellent article.
on Jun 27, 2005
The same madnesses that brought us the Dahmers and Geins of the world also brought us the Poes and the Van Goghs


Equating the first set with the second set is not something I would do. I see your point, but fans of Van Gogh and Poe are not going to be too appreciative.


I don't know, I thought it was an excellent use of opposites to illustrate a point.

I also agree with the gist of the article. Many people these days seem to have lost touch with much of the simpler and more beautuful aspects of life.

I think a lot of it has to do with our "in a hurry" technological culture. Since I've started cycling to work, I find that not only do I actually enjoy the trip, but at the much slower speeds and being basically out in the open, I notice all of the little details that many people whiz past in the cars and never get to see. It's kind of nice to slow down and experience life instead of just speeding through it.

I also agree about the whole "better life through chemistry" thing. I dropped the narcotic pain killers at the earliest opportunity as I dislike being drugged all the time. Maybe for some people it's easier than actually dealing with life.
on Jun 28, 2005
Interesting and thoughtful article, Gideon. And to Poe and Van Gogh, you can add Spike Milligan, Sylvia Plath, Nick Drake, Syd Barrett, 'Skip' Spence, Abraham Lincoln, Virginia Woolf, Peter Green, Ernest Hemingway, Ludwig Van Beethoven, Hunter S. Thompson etc. etc. etc. Otherwise, I would contribute only this:

You say: 'There is almost unlimited potential for human achievement within the infrastructure of a capitalist society ... But I detest consumerism.'
But let's be honest here - how often, in real life, do we see the former in the absence of the latter?
on Jun 28, 2005
Patient: Dr. Dr! It hurts here, and here, and when I do this, it hurts here too!

Doctor: (after examining patient): Ok, what you need to do is, in the morning, take this pill with a full glass of water. In the midmorning, take this pill, with a full glass of water. With lunch take another pill, with a full glass of water. In the afternoon, take another of these pills, with a full glass of water. With dinner, take another one, with a full glass of water. An hour before bedtime, take one more, with a full glass of water.

Patient: Are all those pills going to cure me?

Doctor: No, but if I prescribe enough of these pill, the manufacturers will send me to Aruba, and You need to drink more water! ;~D
on Jun 30, 2005

But let's be honest here - how often, in real life, do we see the former in the absence of the latter?

Very true, and a good point...but I don't have to like it....lol