The journey from there to here

I'm a member of a group whose most vocal elements disturb me. As a conservative Christian, I can quickly scan talk shows decrying the "removal of our rights as Christians" in a public arena.

But my beliefs also run fairly consistent with those of Henry David Thoreau, whose essay on civil disobedience should be read by all Americans.

If (and that's a huge "IF") prayer in public schools mattered to me, I'd be in there praying. I would teach my children to go in there praying. Compulsory attendance laws mandate their attendance in public schools if they are enrolled in those schools, and the administration could not legally expel them for practicing their faith. Sure, I'd be kicked out, but I'd be back. All the court challenges in the world could not keep me from respectfully praying on school grounds.

Similarly, if (again, a huge "IF") my visible presence as an opponent of the abortion industry mattered to me, I'd be at the abortion clinic at every opportunity, visibly praying at the entrance, not blocking any entryways and not addressing any of the patients or workers at the clinic unless I was first addressed. My presence would say enough. Again, I would willingly violate court orders (possibly incurring jail time) to continue doing what I was doing, because I know one thing:

In BOTH of these cases, any attempt to legally bar my kids or I from doing what we are doing wouldn't survive a Supreme Court challenge. They couldn't; there's simply no merit. You see, if I'm not disturbing the peace, if I'm not obstructing traffic, if I'm not threatening anyone, there's very little the aforementioned schools or abortion clinics could do to stop me. And frankly, if my presence wasn't threatening, there's very little most authorities WOULD do to stop me (in the case of the school, my prayer might rightfully be confined to the outside of the building for the security of the students, but that's a reasonable precaution).

I'd probably spend a good deal of time in jail before everything shook out, but I would be willing to do so. You see, a faith worth having is to me a faith worth defending, and if I don't stand up, who will?

But since faith is not a justification for being a jerk, I would have to conduct any protest silently and respectfully. In both of these cases, because the school AND most abortion clinics are run by secular organizations, AND because I have the option (as do fellow Christians), of not supporting either institution, I simply do not see it as my battle to fight. But if I did, you can rest assured, I'd fight it...damn the torpedoes and all!


Comments
on Jun 09, 2005
Yeppers, I agree!!!!
on Jun 09, 2005
Yes, it does seem that whether or not "civil disobedience" is respected seems to have a lot more to do with the cause celeb than the fact that it is an act of "civil disobedience" in the first place.

The far left and far right both seem to expect others to respect their right to civil disobedience, while at the same time expecting the others to respect court orders "preventing" them from their protest of choice.

I also agree with your point about consequences. I hear people complaining that this or that person got fined or jailed for crossing the line while protesting. As long as the law breaking protestors seemed brave enough to "face the consequences of their actions, their supporters seem to insist they shoudn't have to.
on Jun 09, 2005
Well said! The only thing you left out is that you (unlike the protesters from the other side) would get no press and there would be absolutely no one out there supporting your right to do what you were doing. Freedom of the press was never ment to become what it has become today!