The journey from there to here

(Note to Gene Nash: I actually had this blog in mind well before your comment on LW's thread).

One of the things that irks me in this country is the number of people who seem entirely incapable of living within their means. On Little_Whip's thread about minimum wage, for instance, one reader makes the comment that you are in trouble if you make $45K a year because a house costs $240K and a car costs at least $20K. Of course, it was pointed out repeatedly how wrong he was, but I'm sure he didn't pay much attention.

For one thing, the median cost of housing across the USA is $206K. Some places cost more, others cost much less. Sure, you can't always take your job with you, but if you have a job that pays $45,000 a year or better and you can't make ends meet, it's probably in your best interests to move elsewhere.

$45,000 a year, for those keeping score at home, is between $3500-4000 a month. Even in some of the most expensive cities, you can find an apartment for less than $1200 a month. It's not the same as owning your own home, but 1) there's no constitutional right to own your own home and 2) it's a living. It may not be an extravagant living, but you can and should be able to make it on far less. Most families, in fact, do just that.

So how does one make it on a paltry salary? Simply by following Gideon's rule: NEVER pay retail. Thrift stores aren't always your best bet for secondhand clothing, as they've been "picked" by resellers, but you can still find a few values there, added to the values you find at garage sales. Buying closeouts at the end of the season and buying "factory seconds" are other ways to stretch your clothing dollar further. Always look for clearance merchandise and shop at Dollar Stores (a corollary to Gideon's Rule: WalMart's too expensive!).

Food works the same way. Look for bargains at dollar stores that don't specialize primarily in foods and "shop the ads". As a rule, don't use coupons, as  they're usually for overpriced items in the first place (the exceptions to this are for foods where you are "brand loyal" and would buy the brand anyway, and anything free). Bigger cities have "surplus" stores (dented cans, etc), and you can usually (though not always) save if you buy in bulk. It doesn't pay, however, to buy 50 pounds of kumquats if you're not gonna USE 50 pounds of kumquats. And I never buy less than 24 rolls of toilet paper at a time.

Electronics, DVD's? Two words: PAWN SHOP. They are full of practically new merchandise from people who bought items they couldn't afford, and you can usually negotiate an extra 10-15% off the purchase price (I have always been able to; no exceptions).

Books are the gold in many thrift stores. Put simply, books just don't sell, especially bestsellers. So you can usually get them at a bargain price. Add to that "friends of the library" book sales held at most libraries from time to time, the aforementioned rummage sale and estate sales and auctions.

There is absolutely no reason in this day and age that you have to pay retail for ANYTHING. With a little creativity and a good deal of research, you can ALWAYS find a better price and make your "paltry" $45,000 salary go a little further.


Comments (Page 1)
2 Pages1 2 
on Jun 03, 2005
Internet stores are also cheaper if you want to buy anything entertainment related. Since there is so much competition among the stores, the prices are lower than average.

Another tip: buy used. My rule of thumb is if the outside looks taken care of, the rest of it was, too.

Also: sell old stuff you don't want. You can make some extra cash that you can go towards something else. I'm not an Ebay'er but I support the concept. If it's just lying around, get rid of it.Someone out there is looking for it, even though it may be junk for you.
on Jun 03, 2005
Another?  Day old Bread stores!  We grew up on that stuff.  It might be a little stale, but edible and nutritious.
on Jun 03, 2005

Dr,

Yup. And its the ONLY way we can afford the whole grain, nutritious bread (which, by the way, freezes well!)

on Jun 03, 2005

(which, by the way, freezes well!)

In our day, the freezers were not that good, so it always came out with the bottom of the slice as hard as a rock!  But the rest was edible.  When I went to college, I became a veal kid as I loved the fresh bread and whole milk!  And when I did not like the entree's (about once a week), that is all I ate.

on Jun 03, 2005
Simply by following Gideon's rule: NEVER pay retail.


That's my rule too. That's how we managed on D's pay alone. I stayed home to raise kids, and we made do.

I still shop at thrift stores, I still buy things on eBay, and I love to yard sale. I very rarely buy things at full price, I'm a huge fan of sale and discounted clothing and other stuff.
The only thing I won't do is buy secondhand shoes. However, I do wait until Payless has a 'Buy One Get One half price' sale to buy the kids shoes (and my shoes sometimes too). Underwear too....not buying used knickers. But, you can get 6 pairs for $5 or so at Walmart.

I also make my own cleaning products; the staples for which are ammonia, white vinegar, baking soda and borax.
on Jun 03, 2005
Living within your means. hmmmmmmmmm a concept that seems to escape the bleeding hearts.
on Jun 03, 2005

dharma,

same here on the shoes and underwear. But underwear can be gotten at the dollar store (this is where looking for "seconds" helps), and as far as shoes, you wait for payless' inevitable "Buy one get one half off" sale.

In 1987, I made one of the worst mistakes of my life, in retrospect. I bougt a pair of "Air Jordans" at $15 on clearance. Those same shoes are worth a mint now, but I wore them, I didn't hang onto them!

on Jun 03, 2005
Books are the gold in many thrift stores. Put simply, books just don't sell, especially bestsellers. So you can usually get them at a bargain price. Add to that "friends of the library" book sales held at most libraries from time to time, the aforementioned rummage sale and estate sales and auctions.


Agreed. I just picked up a couple of books at Value Village for $3 CDN each. Not too bad. I like it when they have their $1.99 or $.99 sales on books.

Or they have this place where you can go borrow books for free as long as you bring them back on time. It's called the public library.
on Jun 03, 2005

yup. And at many of them, you can check out movies as well. Cheaper'n Blockbuster.

We don't even have cable. We allocate half of what we would spend on cable each month to DVD purchases, because DVD's are a resellable commodity should we find ourselves strapped at a later time; the same can NOT be said for cable TV. True, it means we don't own a wide selection yet, but we can always supplement what we have with library videos.

Oh, and we NEVER rent videos. For the cost of a couple of rentals, I can buy the video used a few months following its release.

on Jun 03, 2005
I definitely agree with the spirit of your article--and I am sure that people can make do with much less than they do currently, and still be fine.

However, since everyone is agreeing with you, and that's no fun , I thought I'd throw in some counter arguments as well.

$45,000 a year, for those keeping score at home, is between $3500-4000 a month.


Just to clarify, that is before taxes. After taxes, you are looking at closer to 2500-2800/month. Still not paltry, but significantly less.

Even in some of the most expensive cities, you can find an apartment for less than $1200 a month.


I must live in a uber-expensive city then (Washington, DC). I assume that we are talking about families here--not just your average single-dom (me). My three bedroom apartment costs $2300/month. The average studio apartment around here is around $1,000 and I don't know anyone who pays less than $1400 for a two bedroom (mainly a one-bedroom with someone living in the den).

For one thing, the median cost of housing across the USA is $206K.


Oh, how I wish this were an average housing market. My roommate just bought a 1 bedroom condo for 315K--to me, that is crazy--but that is average around here and the market just keeps going up.
on Jun 03, 2005

Just to clarify, that is before taxes. After taxes, you are looking at closer to 2500-2800/month. Still not paltry, but significantly less.

Assuming no kids. If you have kids, change your withholding, and the take home pay is greater. If you have no kids, you can live rather cheaply anywhere in the US

on Jun 03, 2005
because DVD's are a resellable commodity should we find ourselves strapped at a later time; the same can NOT be said for cable TV.


DVD's are also a re-usable commodity...well, until you get bored of seeing Spaceballs for the 174th time.

Also you can share re-usable commodities with others. Say you have a DVD collection and your neighbor has a DVD collection. If you share, you both have twice the entertainment at no extra cost.

Sharing can also come in handy with your kumquat example. If you and 9 of your best friends decide to go together on 50 pounds of kumquats, then you only pay for 5 pounds of kumquats, and it's probably a lot cheaper than buying 10 5 pound bags.

Hmmm...maybe kumquats isn't the best example, but you get my drift.
on Jun 03, 2005

I must live in a uber-expensive city then (Washington, DC). I assume that we are talking about families here--not just your average single-dom (me). My three bedroom apartment costs $2300/month. The average studio apartment around here is around $1,000 and I don't know anyone who pays less than $1400 for a two bedroom (mainly a one-bedroom with someone living in the den).

You do.  I am not sure of the exact ranking, but top 2 or 3 is not out of the question (I think Marin Co is number 1).

If you want to commute, you can get twice that for half the price down in Fredericksburg.  But then you have to fight the traffic every day.

on Jun 03, 2005

shades,

Yes, DC is one of the most expensive areas to live in the country. But a quick search including surrounding cities found many choices in the $1200-1500 range...a little higher than my estimate, but once the withholding differences are accounted for, well within the budget of a $45,000 wage earner.

(source: http://www.forrent.com/search/results.asp?r=6154748 ).

And I'm sure if I lived there I could find cheaper places than these. I always do. Not to say it's not prohibitively expensive, but that living fairly inexpensively CAN be done.

on Jun 03, 2005
If you have no kids, you can live rather cheaply anywhere in the US


I disagree with the "anywhere" bit. Like I said, a studio apartment is pricy in these parts and even with roommmates, I'm paying quite a chuck of my salary to my landlord each month.

If you want to commute, you can get twice that for half the price down in Fredericksburg. But then you have to fight the traffic every day.


As it is, my commute is 45 minutes each way and I only live 3.5 miles from my office--I don't think I could handle living any further out--the roadrage would be the end of me!
2 Pages1 2