The journey from there to here

Don't get me wrong, I am not an "open borders" advocate in the traditional sense. Frankly, our borders ARE open, all we ask is that you obey US law to get here.

But I do have compassion for illegal aliens who have crossed the border from Mexico, as long as they're here for honest purposes. After all, these are men and women trying to provide the best opportunity they can for their family. Most know what they are doing and assume the risks; when they are casualties of those risks, they don't get my sympathy, but they do get my understanding.

I am a firm believer in civil disobedience. But with civil disobediance comes the responsibility to pay the penalty if your actions are discovered. If the situation were reversed, I'd be across the Mexican border in a heartbeat, if that's what it took to provide the best opportunity I could for my family.

While I do sympathize, I don't advocate putting water stations in the desert. I DO advocate for programs like the minutemen program that try to apprehend illegals, so long as the law is followed in their apprehension. But I cannot help but understand the mentality of many of these workers.

When I first worked with a good number of illegals, in the mine, I didn't understand. But through the months, these men became more than just coworkers; my life could well depend on the trust that had to develop between us. As I came to know their stories, their families, their hopes and dreams, one thought struck me above all others:

We weren't so different after all.


Comments
on May 19, 2005
Interesting take. I see what you're saying. But I admit: I'm having a hard time reconciling "illegal immigrant" and "honest purposes". In my book, the dishonesty of "I am a criminal" waaay trumps the honesty of "I'm being honest with you about my criminality."
on May 19, 2005
Take a minute to get to know anyone and, if your mind is open, you always find what you said to be true. We are all the same.
on May 19, 2005
We are all the same.


I CALL BS!!! We are not all the same....geez, i can't stand it when people believe that....are we all white, do we all speak english, or french....hmmm? B'ah
on May 20, 2005
Dude, the thing is these people are here ILLEGALLY!! Yeah, I know that most want to come here and work, and that's respectable, but they need to obey the law and wait in line. What's that say to the Asians, the Europeans, and the Africans who want to come here and have to wait when these people just sneak across the border and are welcomed in by the leftists and "world citizens" and given driver's licenses and amnesty from politicans who want to cater to grab their votes?
on May 20, 2005
An excellent article, Gid. Thasickness and stute, by all means, these people have to face consequences for breaking rules if we're going to have rules. And I am not an open borders advocate either (anymore, partly because of JU). But how about you go and meet some of these people and hear their stories and I think you'll see it's not as cut and dried as you make out. Do you think that people oppressed by the Taliban received a brochure in the mail advertising the benefits of going through the refugee application process? As I outlined in a recent series on refugees on my blog (excuse the plug), they often have never even heard of Australia or the USA before they set out, but they know it's leave now with a people smuggler, or leave later in a coffin (or whatever burial procedure they might ascribe to). Any honourable person who cares about their life and their family would do the same.
on May 20, 2005
An excellent article, Gid. Thasickness and stute, by all means, these people have to face consequences for breaking rules if we're going to have rules. And I am not an open borders advocate either (anymore, partly because of JU). But how about you go and meet some of these people and hear their stories and I think you'll see it's not as cut and dried as you make out. Do you think that people oppressed by the Taliban received a brochure in the mail advertising the benefits of going through the refugee application process? As I outlined in a recent series on refugees on my blog (excuse the plug), they often have never even heard of Australia or the USA before they set out, but they know it's leave now with a people smuggler, or leave later in a coffin (or whatever burial procedure they might ascribe to). Any Honorable person who cares about their life and their family would do the same.


Sorry champas but the people who are being talked about would NOT qualify for refugee status. At least not in the US. They have most assuredly heard of America. And they only reason they might end up in a coffin is because they're crossing desert to get here illegally. Cross our border the correct way and you don't have to worry on that account. You can't compare those crossing the southern US border with the taliban.
on May 20, 2005

Dude, the thing is these people are here ILLEGALLY!! Yeah, I know that most want to come here and work, and that's respectable, but they need to obey the law and wait in line.

Did you READ the post?