The journey from there to here
Published on May 19, 2005 By Gideon MacLeish In Religion

As most of my readers know, I am a Christian. In fact, in the literal definition, I am an "evangelical" Christian (but I don't like the term, as it has been grossly misappropriated and misrepresented...but I digress). That being said, I tend to dislike many of the methods of traditional evangelicals, most notably the idea of apologetics. This article is the introduction to a series of articles that will underscore the weaknesses of several arguments of those who practice apologetics. It's not done to belittle or discourage them, but to help them to understand why their arguments are often ineffective.

First, let me say that it is my firm belief that apologetics are grounded in the most sincere and honorable of intentions. I really believe that people who use these arguments see them as being an effective way to help others in the world see the truth of Christianity.

The problem is, "It's been done". Again, relying on my personal experience, most atheists and agnostics are intelligent people who have come to their understanding based on examining the evidence to the best of their ability and drawing their conclusions from them. While there are "sheep" that follow their conclusions without studying for themselves, the same can be said of believers of any philosophy or religion, including and especially Christianity. When you hand them, Lee Stroebel's latest, you're probably the 3,564th person to do so, and when you refer them to Josh McDowell, rest assured that they have had that name mentioned to them before, even if they haven't actually read the material. The problem with both of these intelligent men is they're trying to transfer their own faith experience onto others. You just can't do that.

Apologetics, while sincere are, in the hand of certain people, more weapons AGAINST them than for them. For, you see, when an atheist or agnostic can successfully challenge all the statements of the apologist, they feel empowered and more firmly implanted in their position. In speaking with other people, I have never been able to use these arguments because I see the flaws in them myself. And if I see the flaws in them, an intelligent opponent will eat me alive.

So look at these articles for what they are, if you are inclined to practice apologetics. They will help you grow as a person and as a Christian.


Comments
on May 19, 2005
So in other words, you're not humble?
on May 19, 2005

Icon,

With all due respect, I've DONE that article.

http://gideon-macleish.joeuser.com/index.asp?AID=73445

Off topic, though