The journey from there to here

I just got the news today that my friends' world came to an end yesterday. The state of Texas made a final determination that they could not have their three children returned to them.

This case began after the father decided to stop working full time. He was not receiving government aid (an important point in this discussion). They decided they didn't need "public" utilities, and allowed them to be disconnected. Every day, they would haul the water they needed from the local park.

While that doesn't represent a lifestyle I would choose, it's not supposed to be illegal to not have public utilities. They were paying their rent and feeding and clothing their children.

The county social workers felt otherwise. They removed the children and stipulated that the father go to work full time and that they have all utilities turned on to regain custody of their children.

They did this, and the father has been working for over a year with the state road crews, but the county decided it wasn't going to return their children anyway, even though the family FULLY COMPLIED with the requests of the county.

This is TOO MUCH; do the statistics on children who die or are abused in foster care, and you find appalling numbers; made even MORE APPALLING by the fact that these children were under the
"protection" of the state. I don't NEED to look at statistics personally; all I have to do is look at my own experiences and those of my siblings; further research supports the fact that our experiences were more common than not.

But we live in a society where people insist on our dependence on the state. Where the state is regarded as a better parent than the two who gave birth to the child. And where the state can, at its own discretion, remove your children or those of any "citizen" of the United States, without due process, without the parents' right to legal representation, and without recourse.

What makes me even sicker is that we stand for it.


Comments
on May 06, 2005
A nice pair of stories to start a friday with.  I hope that these children are not used as Guinea pigs as well.  I am sorry for the father.  If I could do anything , I would.  Maybe start a fund so he can hire a damn good lawyer?
on May 06, 2005

Dr. Guy,

Personally, I'm preparing a "Parents' Bill of Rights", and trying to find a Congressman or Senator to sponsor it. Among the proposals would be parents' right to representation, the legal standard of innocent until proven guilty that is SUPPOSED to apply to criminal charges, and civil and criminal recourse against social workers who do not comply with judicial orders (and yes, this happens more often than most would think...and usually with NO consequences to the agency). It may not ever be more than political eye candy, but it's worth a shot!

on May 06, 2005
These Social Worker Stormtroopers should be treated by everyone who knows them as the worst of child abusers.

It is the utlimate in hypocrisy that the American SS accuses anyone of child abuse when the Social Services are the embodiment of government sponsored child abuse.

The joke of a judge deserves castration and everyone who comes in contact with these particular social service clods should be freely spit on them.

That being said, I have known many good and sincere people who work for Social Services. I have also known many great foster families. The problem is, Social Services itself doesn't seem to care to make a distinction between the great and the gross.

A pox on any Social Service storm trooper who would consider running water a qualification of fit parenting.
on May 06, 2005

Para,

Precisely. Interesting how many of our great leaders grew up in the kind of poverty that would be justification for removing someone's child in this day and age.

on May 06, 2005

Personally, I'm preparing a "Parents' Bill of Rights", and trying to find a Congressman or Senator to sponsor it. Among the proposals would be parents' right to representation, the legal standard of innocent until proven guilty that is SUPPOSED to apply to criminal charges, and civil and criminal recourse against social workers who do not comply with judicial orders (and yes, this happens more often than most would think...and usually with NO consequences to the agency). It may not ever be more than political eye candy, but it's worth a shot!

Best of luck to you and him!

on May 06, 2005
http://www.nccpr.org/newissues/2.html A very well written piece I found. It details how, in Illinois, child abuse deaths went UP when the state "cracked down".