The journey from there to here
Published on March 11, 2005 By Gideon MacLeish In Current Events

Don't let the title fool you. This is not an attempt to compare the Iraq war with Vietnam. The political reasons for both, as well as the military strategies employed in each, are completely different.

But there is one similarity that even the most flag waving Republican must concede. This is an unpopular war (although, I believe, more due to media spin than due to personal conviction...but that's just my opinion).

I am beginning to think we have learned one thing from Vietnam, and that heartens me a good deal. I was listening to a radio station today as they welcomed home a soldier who was returning. This is a station that has spent no small amount of time broadcasting the negative news of the war, and which, it is clear, has producers who do not support the war. But, it seems, at least, they are willing and able to separate the war from the soldiers who serve and realize that, no matter HOW you view the conflict, our soldiers deserve credit for doing their job. Put simply, if a soldier allowed his/her editorial opinions to affect how they served, we'd all be speaking Russian right now.

I thank the station and the press that I have seen, at least, for doing the right thing.


Comments
on Mar 11, 2005
"The political reasons for both, as well as the military strategies employed in each, are completely different."
How? Fighting against guerillas with a far-better-equiped modern army? Setting up bogus elections while harping about enlightening high voter turnout? To help 'free' and 'liberate' a country from the evil enemy? (Communist/Terrorist). The one difference is that in Vietnam the US military was restrained and unallowed to go in tough to finish the war. In Iraq, the US is using insane amounts of lethal unrestrained force with no worries about repercussions or indictment.
on Mar 11, 2005
Reiki,

I'm not even going to start. The facts are there, you choose to ignore them. Anything I can say has been said so many times over, and I'm not going to give you a chance to attack.
on Mar 11, 2005

This is an unpopular war (although, I believe, more due to media spin than due to personal conviction...but that's just my opinion).

There were 2 reasons that the Vietnam war was so unpopular, one was due to media spin, and the other tho was due to the draft.  I really dont see this war as being 'unpopular' in the respect that Vietnam was.  I see it as more being politicized by the liberals as 'anything that would benefit the Republicans, whether it is good for America or not, must be bad'.

In the final analysis, other that for loony loopy luddite liberals, once shown the true facts of the Iraqi war, and shown the positive results (and the lack of oil that we have supposedly stolen), a grand majority of Americans mourn the loss of the soldiers, but feel that the results are for the best for everyone involved.

on Mar 11, 2005
The facts are there, you choose to ignore them.


He seemed to draw several pertinent parallels. You chose to ignore them.

but hey, that's just my opinion
on Mar 11, 2005
"The political reasons for both, as well as the military strategies employed in each, are completely different."
How? Fighting against guerillas with a far-better-equiped modern army? Setting up bogus elections while harping about enlightening high voter turnout? To help 'free' and 'liberate' a country from the evil enemy? (Communist/Terrorist). The one difference is that in Vietnam the US military was restrained and unallowed to go in tough to finish the war. In Iraq, the US is using insane amounts of lethal unrestrained force with no worries about repercussions or indictment.


Okay I gotta ask......Are you being stupid or obtuese or uninformed or ignorant or what? We helped set up NO elections in Vietnam. And the rest of your post is bogus as well.
on Mar 11, 2005
myrrander,

First of all, his was a sniping thread hijack. The opening paragraph is not the meat of the article; I was advancing another point.

Second of all, it's a pointless exercise to debate the issue now, isn't it? I believe war to be morally wrong, and believe in VERY few exceptions where it was the "lesser of two evils", but feel that the GREATEST wrong we perpetrated in Vietnam was how we treated our soldiers; this article was meant to underscore how we've seemed to grow in that area.

But, thanks for your opinion.
on Mar 11, 2005
but feel that the GREATEST wrong we perpetrated in Vietnam was how we treated our soldiers; this article was meant to underscore how we've seemed to grow in that area.


MOST of us have grown. There are still the extreme left that spats on the soldiers and calls them baby killers. I have seen their ilk with just such posters in downtown Richmond.