The journey from there to here
Published on March 2, 2005 By Gideon MacLeish In Current Events

I am often struck by the incredibly appropriate timing of the cosmos.

So I was no less in awe yesterday when the Supreme Court handed down its ruling against executing criminals who were minors when their crimes were committed. This came just days after the death of Amnesty International founder Phil Benenson, a man who had spent many years working to free political prisoners and to shine a light on the abhorrent human rights practices of many countries. Amnesty International has been a beacon of hope for oppressed people everywhere, and Benenson's legacy will long outlive him.

The Supreme Court ruling rightly states that we must maintain the dividing line between a child and an adult. It does not exempt a youthful offender from a sentence of life without the possibility of parole, but it DOES mandate, as with the edict against executing the disabled, that there be a standard that must be applied before a criminal is considered to be eligible for the death penalty.

Up in heaven, I am sure Benenson is smiling.


Comments
on Mar 02, 2005
Funny... life without liberty is death. Imaging a 16 year old going to prison without parol.

Since prison tends to be just a holding pen instead of a rehadbilitation center, chances are that the childs life is over. Plus, the child will be with adults who will must likely abuse it.

I guess the crime fits the punishment.
on Mar 02, 2005

Funny... life without liberty is death. Imaging a 16 year old going to prison without parol.

I can't say I disagree with you there. However, the SCOTUS decision is, in this case, an important first step. If later reform is implemented, these juvenile offenders will, at least, be alive to benefit from it.

As for your statement "life without liberty is death", most of us live with far fewer liberties than we realize. But all in all, I appreciate the insightful nature of your comment.