The journey from there to here
Published on February 10, 2005 By Gideon MacLeish In Misc

While updating myself on another person's recent article about celebrating birthdays in schools, I was brought back to one of the chronic complaints of childhood, and how it applies to life in general. The justification was given that, to be "fair" to the one child whose parents didn't believe in birthdays, NOBODY in the class should be allowed to celebrate a birthday.

Now, excuse me for asking, but what kind of chickenS&*^ NONSENSE is THAT?

LIFE isn't fair. Some people come into it with a little better footing, some people a little worse. We can't control that. But neither can we expect everyone around us to pander to our inadequacies, to try to level the playing field so that we all reach the same standard. It's also not fair that little Johnny eats dirt, can't talk, and has an IQ lower than his belt size. But is it fair to the rest of our class if the entire class is geared to JOHNNY'S standards, ignoring the educational needs of the other 29 kids in the class? No, Johnny will always be Johnny, and he should be proud to achieve the highest standards he can achieve. But the other 29 have a RIGHT to be allowed to achieve as well, a right that pandering to Johnny to make the class "FAIR" denies them.

Early in our marriage, my wife would go to all the women's group activities at our church. Invariably, these activities would show movies picturing the ideal male and every woman would talk about how "great" her husband was. It would ALWAYS lead to fights within the next few weeks because "Morton does this" and "Jeff does that", until I reminded my wife of some things I do that "Morton" and "Jeff" DON'T do. In short, she was comparing me against the supposed "better" husbands, while ignoring the fact that I provided for the home, was always there for her and the kids, never gave them a reason to feel afraid and threatened in her home, and most importantly, never threatened to leave her alone to raise the kids. She was comparing us against the wrong people.

Or, more to the point, when she would get upset because of the things we didn't have. The problem with materialism is, it becomes a monster that eats you up and can never get enough. I reminded her that, even though we were (ARE) poor by contemporary American standards, our standard of living is significantly above the world's average, and even significantly above that of all but the wealthy elite of 100 years ago.

The Soviet Union attempted to be "fair" to all of its citizens. It collapsed. Cuba, North Korea and China have become totalitarian governments in their similar quest for "fairness". "Fair" is a standard we will try to reach, but never achieve.

The argument always reminds me of the movie Labyrinth, one of my all time favorites, when the main character, Sarah, reaches her epiphany after repeatedly stating her litany of "that's not FAIR!" that, "but that's...the way it IS". I advise a few more of us to do the same.


Comments
on Feb 10, 2005

The Soviet Union attempted to be "fair" to all of its citizens. It collapsed. Cuba, North Korea and China have become totalitarian governments in their similar quest for "fairness". "Fair" is a standard we will try to reach, but never achieve.

So very true, and probably the reason that the founding fathers did not put that word into any of the founding documents.

Life is not fair.  Life is what you make it.  Get use to it.  Or move to Cuba.

very insightful!

on Feb 10, 2005
Just two fairs in life I know of. One is in Dallas, Texas in October and the other is the passage of time. Other than that, I believe we're on our own...
on Feb 10, 2005

Just two fairs in life I know of. One is in Dallas, Texas in October and the other is the passage of time. Other than that, I believe we're on our own...

Must be a texan!  I know one here in Va too!

Good one!  Thanks for the laugh!

on Feb 10, 2005
Schools are trying too hard to make everything "fair" and inoffensive to everyone. They don't want any child to feel better or worse than any other child. They also don't want anyone to show any real uniqueness because that might possibly make some other child envious of what they have. In todays schools all children must be bland copies of one another walking single-file following all the orders of the teacher who is too afraid to actually teach because some parent may be offended by any given part of history/math/science/english and get them fired.

All this focus on self-esteem, on fairness, on being inoffensive is a load of crap, I agree. The *second* you step outside of a school the world isn't quite so considerate/oppressive. Beyond the confines of the public school grounds, no one gives a rats arse about how you feel about yourself or worrying that they might offend you by daring to be different.

It's because of this coddling we have in schools now that people are entering college and are at a complete loss for what to do next. They don't know how to deal with a world that places a great deal of responsibility on them. A world that isn't going to give them a gold star just to make them feel better. If they screw up, it's their fault and they suffer for it. Oh, and everyone's different... there are Jews, Muslims, Baptists, Buddhists (sp?) and more. In this world holidays actually exist (No more "winter break"... people go home for CHRISTMAS).

So now we're seeing pressure to change the way colleges and universities are to make them more "fair" like elementary and high school were "fair". We're raising generations of kids who can't deal with differences, with criticism, with anything but constant praise and false success.

By trying to make everything so "fair" we're being pretty darn unfair to kids these days.
on Feb 10, 2005
All this focus on self-esteem, on fairness, on being inoffensive is a load of crap, I agree. The *second* you step outside of a school the world isn't quite so considerate/oppressive. Beyond the confines of the public school grounds, no one gives a rats arse about how you feel about yourself or worrying that they might offend you by daring to be different.


EXCELLENT! VERY, VERY WELL SAID. WAY TO GO ZOOMBA
on Feb 10, 2005
I Very Blightly skimmed your article but in turn i completely agree with it and it brings to mind several highly debated topics.

My outlook on the entire thing can be completely summerized in a small quote-" When in Rome, Do as the romans do"

I believe that if you come to Americans you should live in harmony with the American way of life.Don't come from another contry and try to explain to us how we should change things.For instance the Pledge of Allegiance-" I pledge allegaince to the flag, of the United states of America, And to the replublic, For which it stands, One nation, under GOD, Indivisable, For Liberty and Justice for all.

We've used this Same pledge for more years then probably anyone in this country is old.Now we have people that feel it should be repremended so that it falls true to all people.Bull.

Face it people this country was founded on Christian Values, And so forever I hope it stays.Live with it or Leave...either ways fine by me ( I'm not a christian either people.)
on Feb 10, 2005

EXCELLENT! VERY, VERY WELL SAID. WAY TO GO ZOOMBA

Ditto!

on Feb 10, 2005
Excellent article Gideon!!!

Anytime my kids cried out with that line, I answered it with, "when did you start expecting life to be fair!"

The facts are, freedom is never free, equality is never equal and fairness is NEVER fair!.
on Feb 11, 2005

Anytime my kids cried out with that line, I answered it with, "when did you start expecting life to be fair!"

The facts are, freedom is never free, equality is never equal and fairness is NEVER fair!.

I tell my kids that when they find the word fair in the constitution, I will make their life fair.  The oldest ones have become constitution scholars, but so far, they have not found it!

on Feb 11, 2005
You sound like my dad..... "life ain't fair and the sooner you get used to it, the sooner you can move on with your life...."

About the kids in school....have you ever noticed that the word they toss around and then ignore is diversity? They want to "celebrate the differences" (ie:homosexuality and ethnic cultures) but if you want to celebrate a different idea...say Christianity or "white" cultures, you are branded a racist and unwilling to accept others...... They only want "fair" to bring everyone to thier idea of "right", not to actually make it fair.
on Feb 11, 2005

You sound like my dad..... "life ain't fair and the sooner you get used to it, the sooner you can move on with your life...."

That was made painfully aware to me when I was in my early 20s.  My sister is 12 years younger than me, and I was visiting my mother, and she was going off about something.  I put her in her place, and then realized I had just sounded like my parents!  Been old ever since!