The journey from there to here

After getting called out over a blog (listed in the HUMOR category, that did NOT point a finger at Focus on the Family OR the "right"), because of my apparent "misinformation", I thought that I would take the time to write my own blog on the subject of this organization.

I was a longtime supporter of FOTF, and, as an evangelical Christian, found their information on children and family to be both informative and helpful. I have a few of Dobson's books, and have mixed feelings about him and his philosophy, but, as with many other authors, I take what I like of his and feel free to throw the rest out. I think he has made many positive, valuable contributions to society.

The qualifier out of the way, I will begin to address the issues I do have with FOTF. Listening to them over the years, their good and helpful advice has been interspersed with their tendency to use their radio show and their influence as a "bully pulpit". What comes to mind immediately is the fact that FOTF joined with the Southern Baptist Convention in calling for a boycott on Disney (for several reasons; the sensationalist media unfairly singled out the issue of benefits for gay couples, but the films that were being released by Disney subsidiaries had as much to do with it as the benefits issue). Also strong in my mind was a drama some nights back about a liberal priest; FOTF took issue with the way the church was portrayed (as the priest struggled with some areas; in other words, was human), and encouraged viewers to watch it and make a note of all the advertisers and write letters to the advertisers threatening to boycott their products if they continued to sponsor the show. I watched it with an open mind and found it to be, in my estimation, quality programming, if not a bit cynical (I can't even recall the name of the show to mention it at this point, but remember the flap on Dobson's show about it vividly).

Dobson's explanation of his opposition to the "We Are Family" video clearly expresses that it is not with the video or the characters that he has a problem, but with the organization that is sponsoring it and their definition of "tolerance" (interestingly enough, the website pulled most of its material off the site after Dobson's remarks, telling me that they, indeed, had something to hide). I have no problem with that part of the issue, and I have no problem (read: ZERO) with Dobson's explanation of his concern that childhood icons have been hijacked to promote a homosexual agenda. It is a valid concern from a father and a religious leader. In fact, I don't even have a problem with MUCH of what FOTF supports. While we may differ in some areas, it's free speech and Dobson is FAR more diplomatic and considerate than many of his conservative Christian colleagues.

The problem I have comes in when we consider FOTF's FOLLOWING. Sad to say, a strong contingent of these followers have a sheepish mentality and will blindly follow whatever Dobson says or encourages (much as with 700 clubbers and Pat Robertson). Dobson knows this, and knowing this, he often encourages action that a blind follower undertakes without thinking, causing stereotypes and misunderstandings to arise, and potentially limiting free speech in the case of moderate, legitimate programs. Dobson also, like many others, seems to have a limited understanding of how the channel changing and "off" button features on his remote work. While this latest attack was not on a TV show broadcast, but rather on a video distributed in schools, his history is long and established in attempting to bully advertisers on programs DOBSON objects to. It is THIS irresponsible mindset that I take to task when I criticize Dobson, not whether he thinks Spongebob is gay or not (sorry, but I am still laughing my ass off over the whole matter...soon I may have no ass left).

Respectfully submitted,

Gideon MacLeish


Comments
on Feb 04, 2005

First, I wasn't "calling you out", I'm just tired of seeing people perpetuate the idea that Christians are in some way sitting around outraged about Spongebob or his show. You say you know that Christians aren't saying it, but if so, what is there to be funny? The imagined image of them saying it? I don't get it.

It is like me saying it is hilarious that you believe you were abducted by aliens. What? You don't believe that? Well, I guess I can always put it in the humor section, right? Does it matter that you don't believe that? Should it keep me from laughing abou the idea that you believe that? I'm not telling you what to find funny, I just hate the idea that people read that and really believe that Christians are sitting around pissed off that Spongebob is a rear admiral...

re: FoTF, you are more of a supporter than I am. I don't like the organization, personally. I hate the fact that their image is imposed on all Christianity, and when people spit the word "Christians" here they are really talking about the FOTFs and Falwells of the world, not the religion itself. I agree with your description of their drawbacks, so much so that I don't like the organization at all.

re:bully pulpits, I think the anti-religious are the ones abusing the bully pulpit in this case. They make a false claim and all of media latches onto it, countless comedians on TV perpetuate it, bloggers go nuts over it, and it becomes yet another reason for people to spit at Christianity.

The "sheep" in this case are all the gullible twits that are ready to believe anything anyone says negatively about religion. Don't get me wrong, I think Falwell deserved what he got and more because of his Tinky Winky remarks. I don't, though, think that it should be used as an excuse to have a witch hunt every time a cartoon character is mentioned.

I think folks like the ACLU, the Anti-Defamation League, and many others have just as much blind control over those who support them. Look at the activism we see here from Liberal causes. I think they are just as blindly zealous as any Evangelical.

on Feb 04, 2005

You say you know that Christians aren't saying it, but if so, what is there to be funny? The imagined image of them saying it? I don't get it.

No, what is funny is that ANYONE, conservative OR liberal (as you said yourself, the gay community has used him as an icon), would be offended by anything other than the juvenile humor of the show (and since it's a cartoon, the juvenile humor is more than appropriate). What cracks me up is frankly, that this evenm became an issue.

As for your comments about the left using the bully pulpit, point taken. It still doesn't negate what leaders such as Dobson have done with their own followers, though.

on Feb 04, 2005
Well, no one seems to be offended. Gays love it, and Christians don't seem to mind it. Granted, I think it is kind of silly that he was deemed "gay friendly" by the homosexual community. I just think the first thing people think about when you say "Is Spongebob Gay" is Jerry Falwell and Tinky Winky.
"It still doesn't negate what leaders such as Dobson have done with their own followers, though.

Nope, and you won't catch me patting them on the back. I'm sick of the PTL Club, Focus on the Family, American Family Association, yadda yadda. They send more people away from Christianity than they ever bring into it. In my opinion, every time someone spits the word "Christian" at me as if it was an insult, I have organization like those to thank.

on Feb 05, 2005
i found this article and the response very interesting.

it's fair to say that i hail from the opposite side of the spectrum from both of you. i must admit that i tend to cringe when jerry falwell or PRob fires up a mic. i know nothing about these guys as individuals, but what ive seen seems to indicate that they spend a lot more time focusing on the sexual orientation of cartoon or muppet characters than something like, say, violence in cartoon shows. no one hates teletubbies more than yours truly, but i have to imagine that the show, beyond making nitwits out of our children, is doing less damage to their impressionable young minds than other things that they are probably taking in.

i am a fervent religious debater, but my interest stems first and foremost from a metaphysical wonder about the universe. i had huge-hearted debate partner in college who happened to be a southern babtist. that's where i learned that people, even if their religious structure is very different, tend to be more alike than not if they really care about things like purpose and truth.

but it never ceases to amaze me that people can be so judgmental, so certain in their own correctness and other people's incorrectness.

er, what was i talking about? another unfortunate hijacking performed by a sleepy tenente. sorry gideon. i hope you find something relevant in all this blather. yikes.

tbt
on Feb 05, 2005
stinkin double post