The journey from there to here
Published on April 22, 2007 By Gideon MacLeish In Current Events

Not long ago, Myrrander wrote an article about the war. While I didn't agree with his position, there was part of his sentiment I agreed with, and I understood.

I don't comment much on blogs about deployments, about separation of military spouses from their families, because there's truly not much I can say. I hate to see the families going through the uncertainty of separation, of deployments stretching into infinity.

As to whether the war in Iraq was necessary, I truly, I honestly do not know. I know that Saddam was a brutal dictator, I knew that people suffered under his regime, but I also know enough of history to know that when a revolution of any sort occurs, the regime that rises to power is often as bad as, occasionally worse than, the regime that it has displaced. Again, I do not know if this is the case in Iraq, but I do know that we will in almost certainty leave that country with more questions than answers.

And when we leave, we will almost certainly leave for a war on another front, as we continue to wage war against an abstract, against a concept, rather than a tangible enemy. We cannot eradicate terrorism from the globe and simultaneously leave citizens with any liberties whatsoever. We fight ideological enemies with ideas, physical enemies with guns. We cannot fight ideological ideas with guns; in the whole history of humankind, that has never worked, and it is unlikely to work now.

I can't join the call of those who demand we bring them home now, in my opinion, they are as bad as the policymakers and the rulers who have our men and women there in the first place. I want to see them come home, of course, but I want to see it happen the RIGHT way, without leaving a country in shambles, in anarchaic disarray. And I cannot put the blame on the Bush Administration when so many of our legislators, on both the right AND left side of the spectrum, rubber stamped these actions until it became politically unpopular to do so. It's one thing to be a hawk or a dove, quite another to be a shapeshifter, becoming a hawk or dove based on the latest op/ed columns in the New York Times.

But we need to know that our soldiers are coming home. Too many children are growing up without parents, too many in this country live in uncertainty. Our soldiers have fought and sacrificed much for their country, they've done their job, and now it's time to start thinking about how, about when, we can bring them home.


Comments
on Apr 22, 2007
Beautifully said and well written.
on Apr 22, 2007
I want to see them come home, of course, but I want to see it happen the RIGHT way, without leaving a country in shambles

The tragedy is : there is no right way to do that. period. like trying to put the hornets back in the hive after you hit it with a stick. can you do that? ask brad ... he recently wrote a piece about that.

your feelings, and of all those who say the same, is very admirable. the Iraqis must appreciate that, i am sure. but to unshamble iraq now is a physical impossibility. Blame the democrats as much as you can and as much as you like. but to cut our losses and come home asap is the least disasterous way. unless of course there is a hiddden devious neocon agenda.

I let you know soon what i think they are trying to do. Not for iraq of course. iraq's interests is not really their concern , never was and never will.
on Apr 22, 2007
Blame the democrats as much as you can and as much as you like. but to cut our losses and come home asap is the least disasterous way.


I blame BOTH, ThinkAloud. Neither the Democrats NOR the Republicans are working for the people. They serve themselves, they serve the corporations that line their pockets, and they serve the lobbyists that prime the pump and line their freezers with cash. To put blame on one without casting blame on the other would be inaccurate and misleading.

Throw ALL the bums out!
on Apr 22, 2007
While I think ThinkAloud is being douche baggish in his reply, I do like his hornet's nest analogy. I think that's pretty much where we stand right now.

I wouldn't cry if tomorrow it was decided we were through in Iraq and my husband was coming home and it was up to the Iraqis to claim their own destiny.
on Apr 23, 2007
Neither the Democrats NOR the Republicans are working for the people


That is a Given for sure. I was talking about the relative position of both regarding Iraq in particular.
on Apr 23, 2007
I wouldn't cry if tomorrow it was decided we were through in Iraq and my husband was coming home




I cant begin to tell you how i feel about you and your husband and all the rest like you both. my wife turns the house almost to a funeral every time we hear a casuality there.



for what reason on God's Earth should people like you and your husband suffer this? It is insane.



May God reward you both and brings him home to you safe and sound. Same for all people there and their families.



btw, what in the world does "bouche baggish" mean? excuse the ignorance please .... whatever it means, i wont blame you    .