The journey from there to here

I hate getting into endless arguments about abortion. For one, it's not likely to change any minds, but mostly because my views on abortion cannot be summed up in a simple yes or no answer.

Abortion disgusts me. Period. So does war, so does the death penalty, so does poverty. But I also realize we live in an imperfect world, and sometimes we must accept the consequences of that. If there were no murder, no hate, there would be no need for the death penalty. If there were no human conflict, no need for war. If every person saw themselves as their brother's keeper, there would be no poverty. And if there never, ever was a medically advisable case of abortion, no abortion.

Sure, it's nice to be sanctimonious and say "I'm against abortion in every circumstance". But if I said that, I know I'd be lying. See. if my wife were in a position where either she or the baby had to be sacrificed, and she was not conscious to make that decision, I would unflinchingly ask the doctors to save my wife's life at all cost.

Sure I'd weep over the lost child. Sure, I would hate being put in that position. And yes, I pray that God never ever puts me in a place where I HAVE to make that decision.

But I wouldn't regret it. Ever.

See, I have six other children. And every one of those children need a mommy. I consider myself a pretty durn good dad, but I would have a very rough time trying to take the task on alone. And those six children would live their lives with the pain of having lost a mother when it wasn't necessary for it to happen.

Now I will admit at the outset that these situations are a small minority of the abortions performed in the United States. But because these situations are thinkable, because they CAN exist, I believe abortion should be legal. I personally wouldn't want a ream of papers shoved in my face to absolve the doctor of liability in the aforementioned hypothetical situation. In fact, the person shoving the papers in my face would probably be lying prostate 5 seconds after the fact.

But I am not prochoice. Far from it. I believe a woman's choice starts BEFORE conception, and that if she gets pregnant, she should see it through to whatever end. UNLESS the very rare medical exception or an instance of rape or incest occurs. Asking a victim of rape or incest to carry a baby to term is an unthinkable request of someone who's been through so much already, and I, for one, could never demand it of them. If THEY feel they should bring their baby to term, then I would fully support them, but I believe it is an oppressive demand to place on them in a time of crisis.

But in any event the abortion should not be paid for with taxpayer dollars. Abortion goes CONTRARY to the general welfare interests of the nation by decreasing the population, something that may be good for the environment, but is NEVER good for a nation's best interests. And abortions funded with taxpayer dollars will almost inevitably become a growth industry, meaning that many babies would be aborted needlessly and for reasons other than the health of the mother.

So here I sit, not quite anti abortion, not quite prochoice. But I think I'm more normal than most in that regard.


Comments
on Feb 20, 2007
I hate getting into endless arguments about abortion. For one, it's not likely to change any minds


Ditto. Exactly.
on Feb 20, 2007
kudos. I'm stealing a few lines from this to send to my sister.....I hope that's okay with you. I like how you said this....
"
I believe a woman's choice starts BEFORE conception, and that if she gets pregnant, she should see it through to whatever end.
"

on Feb 21, 2007
I guess I would say, I am anti abortion. I feel I have a valid right to say so. My first child could have very well been aborted. In fact I was advised to do so. I chose not to after thinking it over a bit. This is where the rubber meets the road.

I also was attacked by a would be rapist. I also knew that had he been successful, and I hadn't escaped, I would most likely would have ended up pregnant. I had four prenancies in four years, I know my body and this was not a good time.

I thought long and hard after the attack, still very fearful of even going out. I made up my mind then, I still would have stood by my pro-life decision even then. Some may say, since I wasn't raped, and I didn't become pregnant I can't know for sure. I know. I also know someone who was raped and carried the child thru term. She said, it wasn't the child's fault and for some reason this child was meant to be born.

It's not an easy decision, but it can be done and there are many out there that tell the stories.
on Feb 21, 2007
Gideon,

Like you, I'm very much against abortion, in general. In specific instances, I can see the necessity, no matter how distasteful (and emotionally/mentally painful). In the case of choosing my wife or an unborn child, I honestly believe that I would make the same choice, for many of the same reasons you give.

On the classification issue, I would have to say that I'm pro-choice (not pro-abortion, as most of the vocal pro-choice folks seem to be nowadays). I believe that, no matter what my PERSONAL beliefs about the practice are, it's it individuals responsibility to make their own decision on the subject. I may disagree with the choice they make, but I do not have the right to make that decision for them. I can let them know my views, and why I believe that way, but the choice, ultimately, is theirs. It urks my wife to no end, some times, but I'm pro-choice on a lot of different topics. And it all boils down to the fact that *I* do not have the right to choose for someone else what to believe/do.
on Feb 21, 2007
Gideon,

I agree with you on the wife vs. baby thing. I'm pretty sure my wife would be the opposite, but that's because she wouldn't have to be the single parent left with the children. I know I couldn't handle it, and my children need two parents.

I disagree with the other exceptions you give, however. You say this person has been through so much that you can't expect them to have the baby. I say, the scars from choosing the end the life of their baby, no matter how unwanted or messed up it might have been, will be worse than the scars from carrying to term and having the baby. BUT that's just my opinion. And I could be wrong. Nobody will ever know, however, because nobody really knows how it would feel to choose something they didn't choose.

Also, there are plenty of people who have not made up their minds about abortion, and it is for their sake that the argument goes on. And you never know when someone is going to be considering terminating a pregnancy and have their mind changed.