The journey from there to here

When a white person in America addresses the issue of race, it is virtually certain they will be reminded of our country's history of racism. But while slavery certainly makes up a significant part of our history, it is my contention that the United States of America was ultimately the catalyst for the dismantling of slavery since its very inception, and that the charges levelled against her are revisionist and wrong.

You see, if prostitution is regarded, as it so often is, as the world's oldest profession, then slavery is easily the second. As we began life on this planet, wars and conquests led leaders to add vanquished foes to their workforce through slaver, and it wasn't long before the practice became vital to the economy. Virtually every culture has at one time or another held slaves. Slavery as it existed in the US was only unique in that it was so predominantly an issue of race (although not exclusive -- indentured servants were slaves every bit as much as any slave of African descent). Most slaveholders prior had taken slaves of captive cities and cultures, and the slaves were usually of similar ethnic descent.

The slaves that existed in colonial times were not "American" slaves...it is difficult to lay a charge for the purchase and possession of slaves on a nation that did not exist at the time. Many of those slaves assimilated into American households as the nation formed.

Our founding fathers considered the slavery question, and there was considerable debate on the topic. Certainly, they could have outlawed slavery in the Constitution but had they done so, they would have almost certainly alienated those states whose economy was so dependent on slavery in the toddler years of the Industrial Revolution. Had the country split, it's quite likely we would have found ourselves back under British rule before the 18th century's conclusion. The founding fathers' decision, while not necessarily right, was probably the only compromise that could be brought about to ensure the viability of our nation.

Almost before the ink had dried on our precious Constitution, critics of slavery were pointing out the inconsistencies. While we would continue to hold slaves for some time, the movement to eradicate slavery had already been set in motion, and it was a burning issue long before the Emancipation Proclamation. 1860 just happened to be the first time we could elect a president that would take a stand against slavery.

At worst, we as a nation are guilty of about 90 years of slavery, not the hundreds of years that "white guilt" would assign us. And even within the nation, the lion's share falls on certain states; many states did not practice slavery, and many states had activists who worked hard to help slaves. And the movement to help those slaves existed largely within various Christian denominations, most notably and universally the Quakers, who took significant risks in sheltering the runaway slaves.

Our history of slavery is not one of which we should be in any way proud. But it is one where the blame has been wrongly assigned, in many cases to people who worked to help bring an END to slavery. The honest men and women who worked so hard to make a wrong situation right do not deserve to be lumped with those who committed such a horrendous practice. The blame for slavery lies solely on those who committed it and/or allowed its practice, and not on the millions of innocents who did neither.


Comments
on Dec 31, 2006
The whole guilt trip conveniently ignores the reality. White American owned slaves - as you point out. White Americans did not import slaves. White Americans did not enslave the slaves. White americans were at one point of the slave triangle.

And most white Americans were at one point slaves themselves. But we ignore those dont we?

No American is a slave in America today. Find one, and I will be the first to compensate them. Show me an "african american" who can trace his roots to pre 1865 America, and has pure african blood, and I will listen to him. Otherwise, the simple fact is that his ancestors were the enslavers as well. As well as the enslaved.

Just as mine were.
on Dec 31, 2006
Slavery has a history that goes back for thousands of years before North America was ever discovered by Europeans. Funny how people like to forget that.
on Dec 31, 2006
Slavery still continues in the U.S.A. America depends on people who are imprisoned in poverty. it is also the most bigoted nation in the world. Patriotism equals Ultra Nationalism. The U.S. seems to have bigoted stereotypes for every nation it is aware off, i.e. the rest of the world (the other 95%). It has the lowest minimum wage, the most expensive and therefore the poorest health care system and the most backward public education system of all OECD countries, and is a (possibly the only) "Western" country to still carry out the barbaric practice of capital punishment. American justice depends purely on wealth and is totally divorced from truth. These factors and many others make sure that if an American is born into the wrong circumstances he/she will always be a slave. I am an Australian and our own government follows the U.S. blindly in most things. Soon I will be forced to move to a civilised country like New Zealand or one of the Scandinavian countries where all people are regarded as worthwhile, freedom is still important and not given away through fear on a daily basis. I suggest you look at your own history. Read the quotes of the "Founding Fathers" i.e. the ones generally ignored. Jefferson is the most interesting.
Slavery has existed in the U.S. since the Europeans arrived and still exists today. its not even well hidden.
on Jan 02, 2007

I am an Australian and our own government follows the U.S. blindly in most things.

How much time have you actually spent in the United States, living here, observing our system? Your post was full of so much garbage I don't even know where to begin.

Imprisoned in poverty???? 13% of the people in the US live below the poverty threshhold, a threshhold that is ridiculously high on a world scale. With 20% of the world's population living on less than $1 a day US, and about 50% living on less than $2 a day US, it is noteworthy to mention that almost NONE of the American poor live at that level. Our poor almost universally have running water, television sets, and yes, even computers. The myth of oppressive poverty in America is exactly that: a myth. The trth is, we have incredible affluence, almost TOO much of it.

As for bigotry, how can you write what you just wrote and not see the blatant hypocrisy? Have you met every American? Have you met 50%? Have you met even 1%? I sincerely doubt you've perseonally come to know 3 million Americans to get such an authoritative sampling. Your denunciation of our bigotry is in itself the ultimate example of nationalistic bigotry.

I was born in a rather poor family, and I've had no difficulty maintaining gainful employment. I could mention many other people in the same situation. All you have to do to succeed in America is to work hard at it.

I suggest you look at your own history. Read the quotes of the "Founding Fathers" i.e. the ones generally ignored. Jefferson is the most interesting.

I suggest you not condescend to me and assume that I haven't read them.

Base your opinions on hard facts, not on political spin. Your post was easily the most ignorant post of American life that I have EVER read...and it does nothing to support your apparent belief that you live in a country with a superior educational system.