The journey from there to here
Published on August 28, 2006 By Gideon MacLeish In Blogging

Allow me to be the first to comment on the new forum layout.

I was kind of taken by surprise because I couldn't access the forum for a few minutes, then suddenly an entirely different layout was before me. It was a shock to the system, as any sudden change can be.

While it will probably take me a little while to adjust, I like it, frankly. The layout is more consistent with many message boards, and will allow me to search some of the forums more quickly. Plus, by putting the name of the most recent reply (as in a message board format), it will save me the time spent going back to articles that I replied to most recently.

It's different, sure, but I think it's put in some good differences, and, to someone already familiar with message boards, it's not THAT different.

All in all, I think it's a good change. Nice work, crew!


Comments (Page 4)
5 PagesFirst 2 3 4 5 
on Aug 28, 2006
I just got on this a while ago, so I am going to explore a bit to see what I think about it.
I see that there are mixed opinions on this new appearance.
on Aug 29, 2006
I have been trying to upload a personal icon, it keeps telling me the upload was successful, but he picture has been corrupted? the pic is a jpeg, so not sure what I am doing wrong, any ideas?


I tried too and have the same problem...
on Aug 29, 2006

On some articles....like the sex before marriage one...there are 42 comments on it and I can only read the first 29.  There isn't a page arrow or anything, so I can't read the other comments.

on Aug 29, 2006
I really don't like them, just like I really don't like them over on Wincustomize. My biggest gripe is I can no longer see the 5-6 most recently commented on articles. You have to head to each section now. Much more time consuming, much less user friendly. Especially when there are a ridiculous number of sub forums like there are here.




my complaint, also....

it does all look "cleaner", though....
on Aug 29, 2006
have been trying to upload a personal icon, it keeps telling me the upload was successful, but he picture has been corrupted? the pic is a jpeg, so not sure what I am doing wrong, any ideas?


I tried too and have the same problem...


Yes Dark Star uploaded mine for me via his site thingy. He said there is a broken link in the upload process somewhere and they are fixing it. It should be up and running soon.

Again I want to say thank you for sorting out my icon pic for me Dark Star, very helpful of you and it is much appreciated.




on Aug 29, 2006
Has anyone noticed that the column on the front pages titled "last posting details "(or close to this ) does not always update immediately who wrote the last comment there?

You can go on one channel and the posts update very quickly and others not, particularly the home page.

I made comments on a thread yesterday, but it is still showing the person before me as the last update (the thread shows my comments, just not the column of last posting)

Ihope you can make sense of my mumbojumbo! I tend to talk myself in a circle and not make much sense, when trying to explain something!
on Aug 29, 2006
If I click on tools of this post and then click on watch this post, nothing is happening? It works on some but not others?

Is the number of posts you can watch limited?
on Aug 29, 2006
Reply #17. Sue's profile is the same as more than one anonymous user I've seen.


Thanks for he link. I can see clearly now.   
on Aug 29, 2006
My biggest gripe is I can no longer see the 5-6 most recently commented on articles.


Actually, it's down there in the bottom. Just not under the forum categories.
on Aug 29, 2006
I'm liking it! It's a bit of an adjustment but I'm liking it. And best of all there's now a 'search' feature! Guys, you outdid yourself! I'm still poking around so.....but good job!
on Aug 29, 2006
My biggest gripe is I can no longer see the 5-6 most recently commented on articles.


Actually, it's down there in the bottom. Just not under the forum categories.


I think they meant on each channels fornt page like we used to have on the forum home page a list of channels with the lates 4/5/6 comments posted, this is the one big down side, having to now go through each channels front page, it takes ages.

All the other features though are great in my book.

getting back to did any one notice - i clicked open my posts - some of the posts have comments on today, I know that for a fact as i have seen them, but this page still shows yesterday as the last comment and total comments made?

Is anyone else experiencing this problem?
on Aug 29, 2006
Dark Star or anyone else in the know - with reference to the pics option on my account image update

you suggested putting the pics on via wincustomize, I went there to try to upload personal photo and got the following message An error occured. Please check the attached file.

You can only upload .jpg files. You have selected a image/jpg. The image is edited in serif and exported as jpeg - what am i doing wrong? how must i do it to get it to be just jpeg?

advice please....... thanks in advance
on Aug 29, 2006
There's going to be some modifications to the overall channel listings.  Also, we just added (today) a new feature so that when you're reading a post, you can see the 5 or so most recently commented posts in the section you're in.
on Aug 30, 2006
Will compatibility be considered later on? With Safari there's no text boxes; with Firefox there's no pictures. Is it likely anything will be done in future to make the new forums more compatible with Macs?
on Aug 30, 2006
I have an opinion....on the new format. It sucks! It's very slow to load, even with broadband. Once it does show then you have to wait to be able to do anything with it including scrolling down or trying to reply.

IMHO it's also not very user friendly and difficult to navigate. This is just my view. Do what you will with it.
5 PagesFirst 2 3 4 5