The journey from there to here
Published on August 1, 2006 By Gideon MacLeish In Politics

We've seen them for forty years, in communities such as Miami's "Little Havana". They have always placed their loyalty to Cuba foremost over their loyalty to the United States, and demanded they be called "exiles". They will not assimilate, as they do not consider this their home.

I have my own feelings on this matter. I believe a patriot works to improve things in their country rather than fleeing their country. This, for the record, is why I didn't emigrate to another country long ago. But many of these Cuban citizens don't feel the same.

With Fidel Castro's recent illness and the aging of his brother Raul, that, then, begs a few questions: If the death of the Castro brothers brings about political instability in Cuba, and a new, democratically based government arises, will these "exiles" return home to the shores of Cuba? Or have they become so addicted to their lifestyles in the United States that they will continue to demand their Cuban citizenship, yet remain on American soil? Furthermore, is this kind of divided loyalty good for America, or does it add another layer of divisiveness where, frankly, some sort of unity is needed?

I have a feeling that very few of the "exiles" will go home, even if conditions change. Yet they will continue to demand the label "exiles", eschewing the possibility of citizenship, even to their second and third generations, born on American soil. I further feel that this is not what is best for America, and that they should make their choices rather than remain in political limbo forever.


Comments
on Aug 01, 2006
Since they are here...I think if Cuba's gov changes and they can "go home" then the US should say..."leave or become a US citizen."

I don't mind if they want to stay and become citizens, but if they don't want the responsibility of being an American as well as the perks, they should be sent packing.

But I don't know much about this whole issue, so that is said from a place of ignorance.
on Aug 01, 2006
Since they are here...I think if Cuba's gov changes and they can "go home" then the US should say..."leave or become a US citizen."

I don't mind if they want to stay and become citizens, but if they don't want the responsibility of being an American as well as the perks, they should be sent packing.

But I don't know much about this whole issue, so that is said from a place of ignorance.


That actually sounds pretty well-informed.
on Aug 01, 2006
I believe a patriot works to improve things in their country rather than fleeing their country.


My father has a saying, those people in Cuba are called Cubans, those who left to other countries are called cowards. I agree. I have no beef with Cubans, but I'm not to fond of people who hide behind miles of ocean to complain about their countries leader rather than face him like a man or woman. I've always believed that the Cuban population is greater than the cuban military and just like small factions take on big Gov'ts in the fight for their contries freedom, so should they, if they really want it. I don't see why Cubans prefer to face the dangers of a long trip thru the dangerous Atlantic Ocean to a country they do not wish to assimilate or call home rather than free their own country. But that's just me.
on Aug 01, 2006

Since they are here...I think if Cuba's gov changes and they can "go home" then the US should say..."leave or become a US citizen."

I don't mind if they want to stay and become citizens, but if they don't want the responsibility of being an American as well as the perks, they should be sent packing.

Well said!  That's what I'd like to see happen too.

I know someone who's parent's live in Miami and who came to the US 30 years ago.  His father is PROUD of the fact that, despite having lived here for three decades, he doesn't speak any English.  He's PROUD of it.  That just blows me away.  Obviously, they didn't like the staus quo in Cuba, or they'd have stayed there.  I'm all for people being proud of their heritage - that's one of the reasons I think America is awesome - but if people intend to make this country their home for the rest of their lives them I feel like America should demand some loyalty from them.  If they don't want to commit to the US in some way, then they should be shown the door and asked to leave.

Just my 2 cent's worth.

on Aug 01, 2006

I agree with your premise.  But I dont think many will go home.  most are second, third and now 4th generation Cubans.  The old ones probably will.  The younger ones (as younger ones are want to do) rebel and declare their citizenship.

Which is fine.  Let them do so.  And let those that consider themselves Cuban go home and make it the country it can be.  As it has the best of most worlds in which to start.

on Aug 01, 2006
I think many will return to Cuba, especially the ones that have managed to save some money. The business opportunities will be enormous if a democratic government springs up in Cuba. If you remember Cuba used to be an Island Vegas and would most likely be one again. Anyone who could get in there and secure some land stands to make a fortune.

I don’t know the situation between Castro and his little brother but Raul would have and opportunity to be quite a hero, even though he has a reputation for being ruthless he has also demonstrated a desire for a Democratic Cuba and has even talked of a post Castro Cuba. Some of the Cubans I’ve talked to say they would forgive Raul’s behavior as just following orders if he now does right by his people. Looks like will find out soon enough.