The journey from there to here

I deliver newspapers to the low income housing projects in the community near us. These are not the slums of the larger cities, but are, in fact, fairly nicely kept, and the people in these projects are usually polite and well mannered.

These housing projects sit about 300 feet from the local community college. Those who are wheelchair bound would find it about twice as long, but still far less than the trips they routinely take to the store, to McDonald's, Long John Silver's, Taco Bell and Braums. The people in these houses could benefit from the education the community college has to offer. And the community college, which suffers from constant under-enrollment, could benefit from the additional students.

And so it occurred to me to point out the benefits the community college has to offer to some of the citizens within these projects. The answers were universally the same, and quite telling: "no, because if I went back to work, it would affect my check". These people, quite frankly, don't WANT to give up their existence, which requires no work on their part, to try to improve themselves.

Now, don't get me wrong, there are some folks within these apartments who don't fit the bill. The lady with MS who is trying hard to live independently before heading to her inevitable, interminable end in the nursing home across the street. The elderly gentleman who sits on his porch enjoying his retirement as best he can. But the attitude of those within this micro community who CAN improve their lives, but WON'T, have driven home a hard truth to me.

You see, for all of our protestations to the contrary, we as Americans don't value independence too highly. Most of us WANT someone else to make our decisions for us, to absolve us from all responsibility, and to remove the risk of failure from our list of options.

But, as any investor can tell you, risk is usually proportionate to potential reward. While removing onesself from the government dole might be a frightening prospect for some, the potential rewards from not being dependent on the government for help make this move more than worth it, in my opinion. And in the opinions of many who have made those sorts of moves.

Henry David Thoreau once mentioned his feeling that many of us lead lives of "quiet desperation". Looking on the faces of the poor and downtrodden in America, I am becoming more and more convinced that is true. They are convinced the American dream is not for them, and that they should complete their journey from cradle as quickly and with as little noise or personal risks as possible. And when we carry their coffins to the open grave, they have left no legacy, no mark, because they never took the risk.


Comments
on Jul 22, 2006
Thanks, LW. I may get some literature on that. I may be pissing in the wind on this one, but it would be kinda cool if somehow I reached someone who DOES want to improve their situation.
on Jul 22, 2006
What you are saying, but DC does not have the stomach for, is Tough Love. Saying no, when the feel good solution is saying yes. That is the real solution. Sadly I doubt any party in DC has the stomach for it.
on Jul 22, 2006
Thanks, LW. I may get some literature on that. I may be pissing in the wind on this one, but it would be kinda cool if somehow I reached someone who DOES want to improve their situation.


What's good about the Ticket to Work program is that it allows the disabled to at least TRY to work without being penalized the moment they do. Take my situation, for example, there are days when I readily admit I am capable of doing something to earn a living, even if it's just word processing or answering telephones. However, there are weeks (and even months) where I can barely get myself dressed without assistance, much less deal with all the painful little tasks working would entail.

In the past, even attempting to take a job and working for a few weeks would have cost me my SSD, and I'd have had to re-apply to get it back if I were not successful in keeping the job, ie: my disease caused me to miss too much time or I was unable to be competitive in my field. (financial services/ marketing.) That would have meant waiting close to a year for a new determination, assuming my application for benefits was granted on the first attempt, as mine was.

In the meantime, I'd have had no income, which is a truly frightening situation for someone without a spouse, family, or other means of support during that time, in addition to being disabled and unable to work. Losing my SSD benefits would have also caused me to lose my Medicare benefits, which would have ensured my continued deterioration in regards to my health.

It can really be a Catch-22, and the system is overly and uneccessarily complicated, but you CAN give self-sufficiency a go without automatically losing your benefits now, I just think a lot of people are unaware of it or are too intimidated by the rules and regulations to risk losing the only steady form of income they have if they screw up.

Who knows what you might be able to do by acting as an advocate for these folks, assisting their understanding of the program and helping with paperwork. You might change someone's life forever, trust me, no one is getting rich on their SSD or SSI checks, and the benefits are usually just high enough to prevent them from qualifying for other things, like food stamps, utility help, or medicaid. If it weren't for Simon, (and my parents) Gid...I'd be a bag lady, and that's the truth.
on Jul 22, 2006
I think another thing to consider is that poverty just can't end at all, at least in nations with the attitude of the US. Right now you can live in total comfort with many luxuries and be considered to be living in poverty. Right now you are poor if you can't afford health insurance. Later you'll be poor if you can't afford to cash out your retirement.

Poverty in America, at least 90% or so of it, is bleeding hearts on the top wanting to feel sorry for someone, and have-nots on the bottom demanding that the rewards of just living be more equal no matter what you do with your life. I don't know how, but we've come to the conclusion that all lives should have relatively the same rewards, and as Gideon says that itself causes a LOT of poverty.