The journey from there to here
Published on July 10, 2006 By Gideon MacLeish In Misc

I have to vent here for a second.

For some time, in working as an activist, I have been working with a family trying to get their children back. But, you see, I have to say in all honesty, they're not TRYING that hard. And I am stuck here trying to be patient, trying to be understanding, but trying to help this family realize that they should be working in a clear and concise manner to have their children returned as quickly as possible.

I know more about the case than most people, as I've sorted the gossip from the facts and I've seen the case files. In fact, I am using the case files as part of my research, with the family's permission. And my honest, objective conclusion was that this was a family that, when their children were removed, did, in fact, need some sort of intervention. The problem is, nobody tried to reach this family in a meaningful, consistent way. Nobody tried to be their friend in a manner consistent with the teachings of Christ, who most in this area claim to follow. They simply judged, picked, prodded, and picked up the phone and called CPS.

But the seizure of this family's children put them into a tailspin, and both went into a pretty deep depression, from which they haven't recovered. The problem is, I think they've become too accustomed to their children being gone, and are having trouble dealing with the possibility of having them returned. Basically, they've known failure for so long that the prospect of success is pretty scary.

If they were the only ones I have seen, I would shrug it off. But they're not. I read an article today where a father accused of abuse committed suicide rather than working to have his daughter returned. I can't understand that. He left his daughter without a father, and forever feeling guilty for her father's death. It's incomprehensible to me.

Being an activist is not only a lonely job, it's a hard one. I try to be objective in my analysis of everything, and, frankly, telling families that they would be better off making certain changes than simply utilizing the "fight city hall" approach is hard because; a) families don't want to hear that. They want to hear only that they are 100% right, and while that is certainly often the case, it is by no means ALWAYS the case, and; because I am fundamentally opposed to the existence of CPS, and, while there are a few "grey area" cases that I wouldn't know how to place otherwise, the fact that even those few cases exist does haunt me pretty endlessly. But the further I go into this, the more I realize that it is quite possibly what I was called to do, what I was meant to do. And that possibility is one I can't run from.


Comments
on Jul 11, 2006

But as you certainly must realize, (and as I found out with my stepdaughter) once CPS is involved in your life they remain involved FOR life.

No, I understand this very much. This is why we chase the goons off. But in the case of the one particular family, it's frustrating because they don't seem to want to pick themselves up and do what they need to do at this point. I can't be specific, of course, but at this moment, situations exist in their life where even a fairly impartial judge or jury would be unlikely to grant the children's return home, and these are changes that wouldn't require too much effort on the family's part.

on Jul 11, 2006
these are changes that wouldn't require too much effort on the family's part.


I can't wrap my mind around this. If someone took my kids from me, I wouldn't be able to sleep trying to plan/calculate/work to get them back.

Of course I don't know their case but I do know people like them, some in my very own family. Perhaps their reasons for not fighting has nothing to do with depression.....maybe its selfishness. Raising kids is often hard financially and emotionally. Maybe life is easier without them. Perhaps they know they can't tell YOU that so they use depression as an excuse.....

Personally I can't imagine being this way....but then my very own mother was exactly such by her own admission. But you can bet she never admitted it to anyone she was receiving "help" from.

Just a thought.
on Jul 12, 2006
Perhaps their reasons for not fighting has nothing to do with depression.....maybe its selfishness. Raising kids is often hard financially and emotionally. Maybe life is easier without them. Perhaps they know they can't tell YOU that so they use depression as an excuse.....


Actually, they don't use the depression as an excuse. I don't think they recognize themselves as having depression. But certain circumstances in their life would indicate some level of depression, which would, of course, be natural.

I'm trying to wrap my mind around this whole thing so I can understand how best to help them. You can't help with solutions until you understand the problem.
on Jul 12, 2006
You can't help with solutions until you understand the problem.


That's true. Good luck Gid they are lucky to have you. Hope they realize it.
on Jul 12, 2006
You can't help with solutions until you understand the problem.


True. And sometimes no matter what you do to help it doesn't matter unless they want to receive the help.


It's great that you found that which is your purpose. Continue in faith Gid.