The journey from there to here
Published on June 6, 2006 By Gideon MacLeish In Current Events

Today, June 6, 2006, is the 62nd anniversary of what has been dubbed "the Longest Day". After years of fighting in World War II, the Allies mounted one of the most well coordinated and largest offensives ever to establish beachheads in France to move inward and destroy the Third Reich.

The Allied victory didn't come without cost, though. 1465 US soldiers died, 3184 were left wounded, with 1928 missing and 26 captured. The entire Allied forces suffered around 10000 casualties in that single day of fighting.

In this day and age when we question every action of our military with very little military knowledge save repeated viewings of "Platoon" and "We Were Soldiers", it is compelling to ask how different D-Day might have been had we met it with the same cynicism we meet current military operations. I am not saying there is a parallel between Hitler's Germany and Hussein's Iraq, but certainly the two situations do not need to perfectly parallel to make us question our responses. What if the men of the Allied forces had been met with cameras and microphones denouncing us for attacking the German "freedom fighters" for simply trying to protect the homeland they had conquered in battle? What if the mothers of the soldiers who died in places like Omaha Beach and Utah Beach had stood up on a 24 hour news network and demanded that their children died to advance the financial interests of our leaders? What if a daily death count had been broadcast on the radio to announce our failures instead of the broadcasts that announced our successes? Would we have had the resolve to change the course of history by defeating one of the most evil regimes of all time?

While I insist that blind patriotism is not, in fact, patriotism, I would also insist that the questions we are asking about our current conflict are appropriate for certain times and places, and that much of what passes for the "anti-war" movement is not, in fact a movement that is ideologically opposed to war (where were these people during the FIRST Gulf War?), but is, in fact, a movement dedicated to undermining our government through popular opinion, and is, through their actions, weakening the nation.

As we commemorate D-Day and the sacrifices made on that singularly horrific and triumphant day, let us remember those who are serving overseas and measure our questions and criticisms with a respect for the troops and,  at least on some level, what they are trying to do.


Comments
on Jun 06, 2006
As a nephew of a United States Army Soldier who landed during the D-day invasion and grew up listening to his stories on the very rare occasions he would open up and tell them and as a son of United States Sailer in the Pacific at the close of that theatre of operations I say Amen.

Amen and Insightful.
on Jun 06, 2006

die Laengste Tage.

A little town in Virginia, on US Route 29 (and where the fighting 29th got its number) hit Omaha beach that day.  And lost 28 of its sons.  The memorial for D-day is in that town due to their tremendous loss.

on Jun 06, 2006
I missed a direct connection with World War 2 (my grandfather, born in 1900, served in WWI and was injured and left for dead on the battlefield in the Second Battle of the Marne; my father was born in 1946 and thus missed it), and while I have relatives who served (I have relatives who have served in EVERY American conflict), it's not the same as being a direct line descendant of one who served. But it does not make me any less proud of those who fought and died.
on Jun 06, 2006
If the invasion of Normandy were launched today, there would be calls for the president's impeachment for the dismal failure that led to thousands of deaths and wounded soldiers. As soon as it was learned that over 1000 troops died in training for that landing, then the "anti war" movement would be calling for investigations.

You are right when you say that much of the so-called "anti war" movement is nothing more than an Anti government movement. We are encouraged to challenge our leaders and never be afraid to ask "why"... however, the people who seem to yell that the loudest rarely wait for an answer... or care to hear it once it's given.

Up until D-Day, the allies were losing the war. The U.S. had very few victories, but stood tall and wouldn't back down for any reason. With far more reasons to pull out than there ever has been to pull out of Iraq, the U.S. stood up to fascism.

Civilians lived through rationing and little to no news from the front. Gas was cheap, but A cards kept it rare at any price. "Hitches" weren't a year, they were "for the duration of the war". It was no rare thing for a troop to spend more than one birthday or christmas in country and many spend 3 or 4.

What we had on D-Day we have shrugged off. Soldiers returned and the babyboom began. Babyboomers learned how to accept their freedoms and demand more. They didn't pass the lessons learned by their fathers on to their kids.

Now freedom is taken for granted and securing it is someone else's job... except for those who are still willing to serve...

The most telling statistic in the war in Iraq is that enlistment is down, but re enlistment is as high as it's ever been... If what we are reading in the press is true, and the troops are hated and hounded whereever they go... why are they re enlisting at record numbers?

The spirit that enabled those men to run off the landing craft towards a wasps nest of gunfire lives on in many of us... it has not died out, nor is it forgotten... unfortunatly that spirit is no longer respected, but resented by the press and far too many Americans.
on Jun 06, 2006
sorry that got so long. ;~D
on Jun 06, 2006
The memorial for D-day is in that town due to their tremendous loss.


We just saw this last year. It's quite a memorial and very somber as well. It's still pretty new and I believe they are still working on it. Well worth checking out.
on Jun 07, 2006
We just saw this last year. It's quite a memorial and very somber as well. It's still pretty new and I believe they are still working on it. Well worth checking out.


Yea, Bedford is not far from Lexington. I am glad you got the opportunity.