The journey from there to here

This weekend, Major League Baseball has been celebrating the 60th anniversary of Jackie Robinson's debut in the majors (which, it must be noted, was the first time a black player played in the majors in the MODERN era, but let's save the history lessons for another day). Along with the celebration of Robinson's debut is the protest of the declining numbers of African American players, a protest that itself brings out the hypocrisy of many in the activist community.

Before proceeding further, please let me note that Jackie Robinson is a hero of mine because he was a tough as nails player who served as an incredible ambassador and probably was a major catalyst in bringing about the Civil Rights movement. I mean absolutely no disrespect to Robinson in anything I am about to write.

But those who crunch the numbers (as, let's face it, baseball fans are wont to do) have seemingly disregarded the fact that baseball has become probably the most integrated sport on a professional level, a sport where Asian, Latin, African American, and Caucasian players are treated with pretty much the same regard. They ignore that the decline has parallelled an increase of Asian and Latin players in the majors. There's also a hypocrisy in their numbers, as when counting African American players, it is not uncommon for them to exclude Latin American players of color. Sammy Sosa, for instance, doesn't count because he is from the DR. In fact, the exclusive group, "the Black Aces" that celebrates African American pitchers who've topped the 20 win mark, has specifically denied requests from Latin players of color to be included.

Now, I may be young, but I know a fair amount about the Civil Rights movement for someone who never had the chance to live it. I know about the struggles, and I appreciate and respect them. But a common goal of the Civil Rights movement was a colorblind society, where race was not the primary consideration, but rather one's abilities.

There's a pretty sound reason why African American players have dropped off. Because to really learn to play, you need to learn on a well groomed field, and a well groomed field in the middle of inner city neighborhoods where African Americans are a majority is a bad idea. Not just for the cost of maintenance, but because open areas in those neighborhoods become magnets for gang activity. Add to that equipment cost, and it's just not a game that's marketable to the inner city. Not when you can play basketball or football with a $10 ball, and an improvised version of the latter on a city side street.

I believe that the Jackie Robinson controversy is, to a large extent, a symptom of what is wrong in this country. As long as we continue calculating equity by the amount of players of a certain color, the race issue will never be resolved. Have these same people protesting the equality of African Americans in the major stood up to protest the lack of WHITES in the NBA? If the protests are there, I haven't seen it.


Comments
on Apr 15, 2007

Thanks for posting an article on Jackie Robinson, Gid.

As I mentioned in my own recent article, I wish I was more gifted in written communication and could write a fitting tribute to the heroic efforts that Jackie Robinson went to to help integrate the sport of Major League Baseball.

Your article touches on other important issues too, especially in light of recent events (the Imus controversy) and even as I sat and listened to Frank Robinson (who was the first Black manager in Major League Baseball) on a local news/sportscast's sports segment.  Frank Robinson was being interviewed about the importance of Jackie Robinson day and he too, of course, lamented the numbers of Black managers in baseball.

While the MLB has a long way to go in the area of front office management positions being offered to persons of color, the point that Gid makes above about how the numbers are "played" to get to points that let some complain about the numbers of people in various positions.  I wish that we could get past all of these issues, and I really wish we could get past the issue of racism in this country to begin with.

on Apr 16, 2007

Beyond the "baseball diamonds in Harlem" reason, there is another reason.  There are only about 750 Major league jobs open.  As the rest of the world has caught up to America in the quality of their play, you correctly point out that now there are more asians (especially Japanese) and hispanics.  They have to occupy some of those 750 spots.  It is simple mathematics.

Those looking for discriminatory reasons are in themselves being bigots as they do not seem to think that any non black/white player is worthy of MLB status (or even a non-american black as you also point out).  And that is their problem, not a problem of the sport.