The journey from there to here

As homeschoolers, it is not uncommon for us to encounter a great number of individuals who are entirely unfamiliar with the practice. Being educators, we usually see that as a good time to educate them about the numerous myths and misconceptions about homeschooling.

However, there is one especially appalling response from these individuals that we must endure on a regular basis. It's especially common among educators.

They often feel the need to spontaneously test our children on topics they feel are age/grade appropriate. They will ask any number of questions and expect my children to perform like trained seals.

While entirely well meaning, it's interesting to note they don't have the same compulsion as applies to public school children. Often, the questions are either so remarkably simplistic as to leave my children obviously insulted (Hint: when you ask an eight year old to "spell CAT", you're being condescending), or they will be so complex that, while they may know the answer, a spontaneous answer would be unreasonable for an adult, let alone a young child.

If you are ever confronted with a homeschooling family and tempted to do the same, rest assured the parents probably know what they are doing. If they are following the state requirements for homeschooling, that should be more than sufficient for you. While most families will politely accomodate you, rest assured that very few of us are actually appreciative of your attempted intrusion.

If you want to ask questions about our curriculum choices, fine. I'm more than happy to answer those; I LOVE to educate others about homeschooling. If you want to ask about structure or educational philosophies, I'm all ears. But if you want to evaluate the quality of our homeschool based on your own highly subjective criteria, it might be wise to bite your tongue and think up another, better topic.


Comments (Page 2)
2 Pages1 2 
on Apr 30, 2006
I have seen several home school educators look down on and belittle public school teachers...it's funny that you have experienced it the other way around.

It stinks that hostility even exists on both sides. I do agree that we both have one common goal, and that is to educate children. However, many things about public and homeschooling are like apples and oranges.

Homeschooling: One on one schooling, flexible schedules, family support.

Public schooling: Uneven teacher to student ratios, time limits, sometimes no support at all.

We both deal with different scenarios...and although the home school scenario is so ideal, it's not realistic for most students. Us public school teachers just do the best we can with what we have

I can tell you that lately, I have been pushed to my limits...doing tutoring everyday and on weekends with no pay, dealing with standardized testing, with needing to keep up with the higher standards expected of us, dealing with paperwork, professional training, etc. It's stressful...but I want to see my students succeed, so I am not giving up anytime soon.

(sorry for straying off the topic a bit)
on May 01, 2006

Cactoblasta has a good question in that....as far as I know, there aren't that many requirements for parents to be homeschoolers.

It varies GREATLY from state to state, ziggy. Maybe you could try a little research on the subject first.

And rest assured, incompetent parents stick out like a sore thumb unless they live in FAR remote areas of the United States. The fact is, if a parent is actively involved with homeschool organizations, they're probably NOT incompetent, as they're taking the time to network with other homeschoolers to find out what works with them.

Until YOUR profession achieves a 100% success rate with students, ziggy, I refuse to accept your demands that homeschoolers achieve that success rate. Yes, there are certainly families who aren't as successful with homeschooling as others, but I can state pretty authoritatively that those families are in the minority; in my subjective judgement, it seems to be a VERY small minority (please remember, in my work, I have dealt with FAR more homeschooling families than you are ever likely to encounter; I have literally known HUNDREDS personally, and I have met THOUSANDS....no exaggeration there).

on May 01, 2006


Reply By: InBloomPosted: Sunday, April 30, 2006
I have seen several home school educators look down on and belittle public school teachers...it's funny that you have experienced it the other way around.

While I am a strong homeschool advocate, inbloom, I realize it doesn't work for every family, and, in fact, I discourage the trend to homeschool because of a gut reaction (Columbine, etc) because of: 1)the way it reflects negatively on those of us who are strongly dedicated to this philosophy of education; 2) the fact that homeschooling requires dedicated parents, and those homeschooling because of a gut reaction tend not to be as dedicated.

All I ask for is EQUAL respect as a teacher, InBloom, NOT greater respect.

excellent comments.

on May 01, 2006
HAHAHAHA

I still can't believe someone started quizzing your kids!

That just cracks me up. Doesn't seem like it matters where you're from...that is just plain rude.
on May 01, 2006
I agree, Homeschooling is a little alien to me but that is rude.
That is just wrong, sorry Gid.

You should have some questions precanned next time to fire back at those Muther Plunkers 'Who was the 7th President' ect... and put them in the same seat.
2 Pages1 2